Is Meghan Markle's New Netflix Show "With Love, Meghan" Genuine or Just a Fantasy?

The anticipation surrounding Meghan Markle's upcoming Netflix series, With Love, Meghan, has spurred a mix of excitement and debate. The series is a reality show that covers her lifestyle from cooking, gardening, and crafting, showcasing Meghan's passion for creativity and connection. However, critics contend it may come across as more of a polished fantasy than a genuine reflection of her life.

‍

‍

The series, which is set to debut on January 15, 2025, invites viewers into a carefully curated version of Meghan’s world. Filmed at a luxurious farmhouse in Montecito, the show features Meghan hosting celebrity guests like Roy Choi, Mindy Kaling, and Alice Waters while preparing meals, gardening, and even beekeeping. The emphasis is on thoughtful details that bring people together, with Meghan showcasing tips like using edible flowers or crafting take-home gifts for guests.

Some critics have dismissed the series as "Netflix fantasy," accusing Meghan of portraying a fabricated version of her daily life. The production’s use of a rented farmhouse, rather than Meghan’s $14.65 million mansion, has fueled accusations of inauthenticity, leading detractors to question the relatability of the show’s premise as a reality show.

On the other hand, supporters like royal correspondent Cameron Walker view the show as a fulfillment of Meghan’s longstanding passion for lifestyle content. Before her marriage to Prince Harry, Meghan ran The Tig, a popular blog that offered insights into her favorite recipes and wellness tips. Walker contends the show aligns with Meghan’s genuine interests and should be celebrated as a creative outlet post-royal life.

It’s undeniable that With Love, Meghan is polished and highly produced, it sets the tone of a lavish modern lifestyle. The point of critics arguing its authenticity is debatable, being that there is a  touch of aspiration is part of the genre’s appeal. Meghan’s show might not mirror her everyday life, but it could still offer valuable ideas and inspiration to viewers.

While the choice to film in a rented farmhouse may seem out of touch, dismissing the entire show as “fake” can be overly harsh. Meghan’s background in lifestyle content and her aim to create a platform for connection suggest there is more substance to With Love, Meghan than critics give credit for. However, the show would benefit from addressing the disconnect between its presentation and the realities of Meghan’s life. Acknowledging the aspirational nature of the series upfront could make it feel less contrived and more authentic.

In all, Meghan straddles the line between inspiration and escapism. For some, it may resonate as a heartfelt celebration of life’s small joys; for others, it might feel like another carefully crafted PR exercise. Whether viewers embrace or critique it will depend on their expectations of authenticity in the modern lifestyle genre.